Skip to main content

PastorWagner.com

Christian Identity Refutation (Part 6)

November 15 2026

Christian Identity Refutation image

Click here for the Entire Series and Outline.

Click here for previous sermon.

Click here for next sermon.

Christian Identity Refutation (Part 6)

 

CI Tenet #14: The early European tribes were really the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel and therefore the rightful heirs to God’s promises, and God’s chosen people.

  1. The ten tribes of Israel were not “lost” ― they were still known when the NT was written in the mid-1st century (Act 26:6-7; Jam 1:1).
  2. Amos prophesied (prior to the Assyrian conquest of the Northern Kingdom – Amo 1:1) that God would sift the house of Israel among all nations, but none of them would be lost (Amo 9:9).
  3. There is no Biblical evidence that the early European tribes were the ten tribes of Israel.
  4. The Europeans are not God’s chosen people nor the rightful heirs of His promises (see CI Tenet #9).

 

CI Tenet #15: After the northern Kingdom of Israel was conquered by Assyria at c. 721 BC, the ten tribes disappeared from the Biblical record.

  1. This is not true.
  2. According to Mauro’s chronology, the northern kingdom of Israel was conquered in 640 BC, not 721 BC (Philip Mauro, The Wonders of Bible Chronology, p.71).
  3. After the northern kingdom of Israel was conquered by Assyria, Hezekiah wrote letters to them encouraging them to return to Jerusalem to keep the passover, which many of them did (2Ch 30:1, 9-11, 18).
  4. The twelve tribes were still around and being written to in the NT times (Jam 1:1) and were serving God (Act 26:6-7).
  5. Anna was an Israelite from the tribe of Aser (Asher) – (Luk 2:36).

 

CI Tenet #16: White people of Europe in particular, or Caucasians in general, are God’s servant people, according to the promises that were given to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.

  1. Europeans, or Caucasians in general, are not God’s chosen people (see CI Tenet #9).
  2. Those who are in Christ are heirs of the promises given to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob (Gal 3:16 c/w Gal 3:29), regardless of their “race” or skin color (Gal 3:26-28; Col 3:11).
  3. People of all nations are blessed through the promises made to Abraham and his seed, the Lord Jesus Christ (Gal 3:7-9).

 

CI Tenet #17: Celtic and Germanic peoples, such as the Anglo-Saxon, Nordic nations, or the Aryan race and kindred peoples are the true Israelites, and modern Jews have dispossessed them of their identity as God’s chosen race.

  1. Nobody knows who is a “true Israelite” (a blood descendent of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob) today, if there even are any.
  2. Even if there are “true Israelites” living today, it doesn’t matter one iota, because God doesn’t care about Jew and Gentile distinctions under the New Covenant (Col 3:11).
    1. Being a “true Israelite” means absolutely NOTHING today (Mat 3:9; Rom 2:28-29; Php 3:3).
    2. Those who are in Christ are “the Israel of God,” no matter what their nationality (Gal 6:15-16).
  3. Modern “Jews” are Khazarian Caucasians who “say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan” (Rev 2:9).

 

CI Tenet #18: Anglo-Saxons (whites) are the true Israelites, God’s chosen people who were given the divine right to rule the world until the Second Coming of Christ.

  1. Anglo-Saxons (whites) are not the true Israelites, nor God’s chosen people (see CI Tenets #s 9 & 17).
  2. No “race,” nation, or people have been given the divine right to rule the world until the Second Coming of Christ.
  3. Christians (regardless of “race” or nationality) reign in the kingdom of God (the local church – Luk 22:29-30 c/w 1Co 10:16, 21) spiritually (1Co 4:8; 1Pe 2:9; Rev 1:6; Rev 20:6).

 

CI Tenet #19: There will be an imminent, apocalyptic struggle between good and evil, with the whites against the Jews.

  1. There will be an apocalyptic struggle between good and evil, but it will be between Satan and the nations aligned with him, and the saints (Rev 20:7-9), regardless of their nationalities or skin colors.
  2. The battle of Armageddon is a battle between the nations of the earth, which are inspired by Satan, and God Himself at the second coming of Christ (Rev 16:14-21).
  3. I know of no scriptural support that the war will be between whites and Jews.

 

CI Tenet #20: America is the Zion of Bible prophecy and will be the seat of Christ’s earthly, millennial kingdom.

  1. The Zion of Bible prophecy is the NT church which is in communion with the heavenly church (Heb 12:22-23, 28; Rev 14:1).
  2. Even if America were the Zion of Bible prophecy, it could not be known conclusively now because prophecy is not understood clearly until after its fulfillment (Joh 2:19-22; Joh 12:12-16).
  3. Christ’s kingdom is the NT church which is spiritual, not earthly.
    1. The “millennium” is the figurative time period between Christ’s first and second comings, not a literal 1000 years.
    2. See series called “Millennialism, End Times, and the Reign of Christ” for scriptural proof of these statements: https://pastorwagner.com/millennialism.

 

CI Tenet #21: All of history represents a great cosmic war between the forces of good and evil. It is all part of a Satanic plot to take control of creation.

  1. Christian Identitarians are correct on this point.
  2. See the Satan series: https://pastorwagner.com/satan.

 

CI Tenet #22: Most CI adherents are white nationalists who advocate racial segregation and the imposition of anti-miscegenation (interracial marriage) laws.

  1. This is abhorrent and unbiblical.
  2. The Bible does not teach racial superiority, segregation, or anti-miscegenation (see CI Tenet #s 2, 3, 9, 12).

 

CI Tenet #23: Christian Identitarians advocate the introduction of a state of racial purity in the US.

  1. It is true that historically empires that desired to subjugate and destroy other nations would mingle people from other nations and cultures with them (Dan 2:43; 2Ki 17:24).
  2. It is true that God wants nations divided and boundaries between them for the purpose of promoting an environment where men can seek the Lord (Act 17:26-27).
  3. It is also true that flooding a nation with foreigners who speak a different language will weaken that nation (Neh 13:23-27; Gen 11:1-9; 1Co 14:11).
  4. Given these facts, a nation would be wise to limit immigration (especially from countries which have religions and cultures which are diametrically opposed to its own) to prevent its culture and morals from being changed (Ezr 9:1-3; Psa 106:34-38).
  5. However, to extrapolate from these facts the idea that the US should be “racially pure” by only allowing white people to live here and only allowing US citizens to marry white people is a step too far and is unbiblical (see CI Tenet #22).

 

  1. “The Identity teaching does not merely result in a particularly radical (and often violent) form of racism. It utterly negates the gospel of grace. The message of Christianity is that God graciously extends salvation to people irrespective of anything which they might imagine would make them superior to other people. “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23). The ultimate conflict in this world is not between Whites and non-Whites, but between God and Satan, between righteousness and sin. Our fight is not with “flesh and blood”—with human beings, of any race—but with the spiritual forces of evil that wage war against our souls (Ephesians 6:12). The Identity doctrine perverts Christianity from a redemptive theology into a racist ideology. It is therefore not truly Christian.” (Christian Identity, Watchman Fellowship, 1999)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to My Blog

Get Notified When I Post a New Blog

You can unsubscribe any time.